Dog Harness Vs. Collar - Which is Better

Opinions vary on whether dog harnesses or dog collars are appropriate. Many dog owners use the collar automatically: you know it, you see it everywhere, and you don't give it any thought. It is good to reconsider your routine and consider whether a harness would be a better alternative than a traditional collar. We've compiled a list of the benefits and drawbacks of collars and harnesses.

Many supporters of animal rights prefer dog harnesses because they protect your dog's throat first and foremost. Wearing a dog harness can also help to relax the cervical spine and neck muscles. The dog may move freely without placing strain on the neck if the harness fits correctly.

The Benefits of Using a Harness

The harness provides several advantages to your dog that the collar does not. Here are some benefits of utilizing a harness to help you understand:

  • If the harness is properly set, the dog will not injure himself if he pulls too hard on his leash. At the same time, holding it back causes it to become more obstructed since the resistance is distributed throughout the body.

  • If your dog pulls on his leash a lot, the harness makes walking him more pleasurable for both of you. This master/dog fight is progressing at a slower pace.

  • The harness gives you more control over your dog's walk, or rather, the direction your dog chooses to go in. A harness is more convenient to use than a collar for redirecting your pet. These redirection modifications are relatively easy for the animal and remain natural since they distribute its weight throughout its whole body.

  • When you want to train your dog, especially for walking, the harness comes in helpful. You may even use the harness to train it to sit or stand motionless. You specify the order with a frank outfit.

Harnesses have drawbacks as well

However, the harness has several drawbacks. The harness straps frequently wrap the chest far too near to the front legs, limiting shoulder blade motion. Harnesses that cover a substantial portion of the dog's shoulder blade should be avoided in general since they drastically limit the dog's freedom of movement. It's especially aggravating when the dishes scrape against your four-legged pal, causing him to twist his elbows outwards. The movement sequence is severely interrupted, with potentially long-term repercussions.

As a result, before utilizing a harness, be certain that it fits properly. If the harness is not close enough to the dog's body and slaps about wildly, it is just as annoying. Because it must be carefully crafted and fit perfectly, a harness requires a lot more responsibility from the dog owner. This is especially crucial because it may be inconvenient and even dangerous when unconstrained.

How to Choose the Best Dog Harness

When purchasing, make certain that the dishes match the following criteria:

  • Material that is light, soft, and flexible.
  • The back bar is long and has strong buckles.
  • slider on the chest area for length adjustment

Tip: Choose an H-shaped Harness. This is the "traditional" harness that everyone is accustomed to. It is an excellent initial pick if you are unclear about yourself or what is best for your pet. However, you must be very careful while adjusting this harness since it might fall off if the animal pulls hard.

What are the Collar's Risks?

Wearing the collar is dangerous to your dog. Each shock or strain is conveyed to the body of the dog. Humans understand that it only takes a "whiplash" to cause pain. It's the same with the dog. A collar, like ourselves, destroys important organs in the neck and produces discomfort.

Headache, back, and neck muscle pain, reduced mobility, difficulty eating and drinking, changes in metabolism, cough, stomach and intestinal problems, changes in heart level, thyroid disorders, negative effects on the lymphatic system, blood circulation, increased stress levels, eye problems, trachea damage are all possible side effects of the collar.

According to a Swedish study, 63% of the dogs in the study experienced back issues. 91% of these dogs pulled excessively or had leash shots. According to comparable Norwegian research, 75% of the 350 dogs evaluated had neck abnormalities that their owners were unaware of.

The Collar's Benefits

A collar is not inherently harmful, but it should be used with caution. As is frequently the case, common sense is the greatest counsel in this situation: The collar should not be subjected to excessive or long-term forces; if your fur nose is always on the leash, a harness is unquestionably the best option.

A collar can be much more pleasant and less bothersome for the dog if the dog is strolling lightly on the leash. It is critical that the dog learns to lead and is not accustomed to yanking on the leash. As long as your four-legged buddy understands this, there is often nothing wrong with wearing a collar.


You should have both available for your buddy, and your dog should be used to wearing both a collar and a harness.  The application then relies on the context and sometimes even the mood. A neck injury can commonly prevent the use of a collar, and a chest or back injury might make the use of a harness difficult. In such instances, it is preferable if your four-legged pet feels comfortable with both options. If you still haven't made a decision and want to buy dog collars, dog collar chains, or dog body harnesses, visit our store in Jaipur. Now you can even buy dog collars online at your convenience through our service. We are considered one of the best dog sellers in Jaipur

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published